May You Be the Mother of a Hundred Sons: A Journey Among the Women of India (1990) by Elisabeth Bumiller is a richly detailed, empathetic non-fiction account of the author's three-and-a-half-year stay in India (primarily New Delhi, starting around 1985) as the wife of a Washington Post correspondent. Bumiller, an American journalist with initially limited knowledge of the country, set out not to write a stereotypical "woman's book" or a judgmental exposé, but to understand the lives of India's roughly 400 million women at the time through personal encounters, travels, and interviews across social classes and regions—from wealthy urban elites in New Delhi and Calcutta to poor villagers in the northern plains, movie stars in Bombay, intellectuals, and health workers in the south.
The title comes from a traditional Hindu blessing ("May you be the mother of a hundred sons"), which encapsulates the deep cultural son-preference that shapes much of the book: girls are often viewed as liabilities (due to dowry costs, limited economic value, and the expectation they will leave the family upon marriage), while sons are assets. Bumiller explores the paradoxes of Indian women's lives—enormous suffering alongside resilience, powerlessness mixed with quiet strength, and stark contrasts between illiterate rural women and figures like Indira Gandhi (cited as one of the world's most powerful women). She questions her own Western feminist assumptions, avoids romanticizing or demonizing India, and highlights how issues like marriage, motherhood, duty, fate, religion, and societal governance are intertwined. The book reveals that the "typical" Indian woman (about 75% of women) lived in poverty, repression, and illiteracy, yet exceptions and a growing women's movement offered glimmers of change. Bumiller finds universality in these stories that raises questions for women everywhere.
The narrative is structured as a personal chronicle (roughly 12 chapters in the original edition) rather than a strict academic treatise. It flows thematically through Bumiller's evolving journey: her arrival and culture shock, explorations of arranged marriages, bride-burning/dowry deaths, rural village life, female foeticide and infanticide, working women's burdens, artists and intellectuals, progressive activists, and broader reflections on history, reform, and paradoxes. She interweaves her own reflections with vivid stories, trying "to understand before I judged," and includes men's perspectives where relevant (e.g., via psychoanalyst Sudhir Kakar on patriarchal pressures). Issues are shown as interconnected, rooted in centuries of cultural attitudes that undervalue women.
Son Preference and Female Foeticide/Infanticide: From birth, girls are seen as burdens. Bumiller discusses sex-selective abortions (via amniocentesis, despite abortion being legal since 1971) and infanticide. In one poignant southern Indian village story, a poor family kills their day-old daughter because they cannot afford the future dowry—highlighting how practices outlawed decades earlier (dowry banned in 1961, infanticide in 1870) persist in silence and desperation.
Dowry Deaths (Bride-Burning) and Arranged Marriages: Marriage is portrayed as a microcosm of society (95% are arranged). Bumiller investigates "dowry deaths," where brides are killed (often by burning) if their families cannot meet demands. She profiles cases among educated urban classes and rural poor, showing how even outlawed customs endure due to economic pressures and family honor. Girls receive less education and nutrition than boys, trained for marriage rather than independence.
Sati, Widows, and Rural Life: Sati (widow immolation) is noted as nearly extinct (banned in 1829/1859), but widows in some areas face ongoing hardship. She visits villages (including references to places like Khajuraho-area women in some accounts) to show daily realities of poverty and tradition.
Working Women and Modern Paradoxes: Employed women (including in cities) juggle careers with full unpaid housework and childcare, with little spousal help. Bumiller contrasts this with U.S. experiences and notes ironies like India's higher percentage of women in parliament (around 10% in 1988) than the U.S. Congress at the time, or earlier legalization of abortion.
Bumiller brings the book to life through specific women she meets, blending elite, artistic, activist, and ordinary voices to illustrate diversity:
Aparna Sen (renowned Bengali filmmaker): Profiled as a high-achieving professional balancing wife, mother, and director roles. She candidly admits she doesn't cope well and speaks of constant guilt: “If you asked what is the most important thing about me, the answer is guilt... Every time I am knitting I feel I should be writing a script... When I am at work I feel, ‘Oh, my poor daughters, they are always deprived.’” This highlights the emotional toll on working mothers.
Kiran Bedi (trailblazing police officer, later Ramon Magsaysay Award winner): Shown as a powerful figure in a "topsy-turvy" world where she controls men's lives professionally. She lives separately from her husband due to her demanding career. Bumiller contrasts her with an average Delhi housewife (content with family duties), showing both can find fulfillment on their own terms despite societal expectations.
Ela Bhatt (founder of SEWA – Self-Employed Women's Association): Highlighted as a key activist building one of India's most powerful women's groups for poor self-employed workers (e.g., vendors, artisans). Represents grassroots empowerment and the emerging women's movement post-1974 "Towards Equality" report.
Gayatri Devi (former Maharani of Jaipur): A wealthy sophisticate exemplifying elite women who navigate tradition and privilege.
Veena Bhargava (Calcutta painter) and Nabaneeta Dev Sen (Bengali poet): Intellectual/artistic figures from Calcutta, illustrating creative women who achieve despite patriarchal norms.
Bombay film actresses (group profile, not always named individually): Off-screen, many defy norms with independent lives; on-screen, they often reinforce regressive values, creating personal and societal ironies.
Ordinary/rural women (anonymous but vividly described): Villagers in the northern plains or south India who endure poverty, infanticide decisions, and daily repression; health workers; and urban housewives. These ground the book in the majority experience.
Bumiller also references historical/contextual figures like Indira Gandhi (symbol of possibility), 19th-century reformers (e.g., Rammohan Roy, who helped end sati and allow widow remarriage), Mahatma Gandhi (mixed impact on women), and critic Katherine Mayo (whose controversial Mother India she engages with thoughtfully).
Overall, the book is praised for its clean, insightful style that makes complex realities accessible without stereotypes. Though published in 1990 (and some data is dated), the core issues—dowry, son preference, work-life imbalances, and cultural paradoxes—remain relevant, with slow progress noted by later readers. Bumiller's outsider perspective adds freshness while her empathy and research make it a compelling, human-centered exploration rather than a polemic. It's often described as a transformative read that deepens understanding of gender, culture, and universality.
No comments:
Post a Comment