In "A Room of One’s Own", Virginia Woolf, when asked to share her thoughts on women and fiction, makes a bold assertion: for women to write, they need five hundred pounds a year and a room of their own. Rather than directly explaining her reasoning, Woolf suggests that gendered topics are so contentious that it is nearly impossible to address them plainly without the speaker becoming the target of scrutiny instead of the argument. To navigate this, Woolf adopts a fictional persona who arrives at the same conclusion she has, imagining the steps that might lead to that realization. This narrative approach encourages the audience to draw their own conclusions from the events depicted, hoping to shed light on the realities faced by women writers. Throughout the story, the narrator illustrates how comfort and privacy are essential for creating the material and emotional security necessary for writing well, and how the historical lack of such security has disadvantaged women.
In Woolf’s imagined scenario, the narrator begins by describing two dinners at two very different universities. The first, Oxbridge—a blend of Oxford and Cambridge—is an old and prestigious institution for men. The narrator notes that centuries of donations have cultivated an ideal environment for young scholars, as seen in the fine food, beautiful grounds, and extensive library. Moreover, these grounds are carefully guarded, ensuring that the scholars’ work is uninterrupted. At Fernham, a fictional women’s college, the food is sparse and unsatisfying, and the environment is bleak. Unlike Oxbridge, Fernham has very little funding, largely because women were not historically in control of finances. The lack of resources and material comfort at Fernham creates a starkly unequal environment. These two dinners serve as a metaphor throughout the essay, illustrating how genius is nurtured in environments of comfort and protection.
The narrator extends this metaphor during a visit to the British Library, where she observes the insecurity in the work of male scholars who write about the supposed inferiority of women. It is only when she considers what she’s read over a meal she buys for herself that she can analyze this anger with a clear mind. From a position of security, she recognizes that these male scholars feel threatened by the idea that their gender may not be inherently privileged. This experience highlights the importance of emotional security in writing and scholarship, which is closely tied to material security.
The narrator tests her ideas by examining the historical canon of literature. She imagines the life of a hypothetical sister of William Shakespeare and concludes that, because independence from men was unattainable, she would have no space to develop her talents, ultimately leading to depression and suicide. The narrator then looks at women writers throughout history, noting that even when money was not a concern, women often lacked uninterrupted space to write. The intense scrutiny faced by women writers such as Aphra Behn and Margaret Cavendish adds a defensive tone to their work, which the narrator feels detracts from their art.
Turning her attention to contemporary literature, the narrator invents an “everywoman” author named Mary Carmichael. Reading one of Carmichael’s novels, the narrator observes that she breaks new ground by focusing on women in relation to each other, rather than solely in relation to men. While acknowledging the novel’s flaws, the narrator recognizes that given how little precedent Carmichael has to draw from, the work is commendable. The narrator believes that all art builds upon what came before it, just as the current state of Oxbridge and Fernham reflects the financial support and space historically available to them. With this in mind, she suggests that if women writers are given money and space, the Mary Carmichaels of the literary world could, given a hundred years, achieve genius.
Finally, the narrator considers the role of gender in the genius of writing. She argues that because men and women lead different lives, their writing will naturally differ. However, she asserts that self-consciousness about gender hinders the quality of writing. This self-consciousness, she believes, arises from discomfort, which manifests as anger. For women, this discomfort stems from a lack of space and financial support. For men, it comes from the need to guard the resources and comfort they have been afforded. The narrator concludes that for women to develop a literary canon of their own, they need the means to live comfortably and the space to focus on their writing, allowing them to create without bitterness, fear, or anger.
Short Essay
In *A Room of One's Own*, Virginia Woolf presents a dramatic setting in which she has been invited to speak on the topic of Women and Fiction. She puts forth the thesis that "a woman must have money and a room of her own if she is to write fiction." Her essay unfolds as a semi-fictional narrative, illustrating the thought process that led her to this conclusion. To dramatize this intellectual journey, she introduces an imaginary narrator who, like herself, grapples with the same subject. This narrator, who could be called "Mary Beton, Mary Seton, Mary Carmichael, or any name you please—it is not a matter of any importance," mirrors Woolf's position and struggles with the same issues.
The narrator's exploration begins at Oxbridge College, where she reflects on the stark differences in the educational experiences and material conditions available to men and women. She then spends a day in the British Library, examining scholarship on women—all of which is authored by men and filled with anger. Finding little historical information on the daily lives of women, she turns to imaginative reconstruction, creating the figure of Judith Shakespeare to illustrate the tragic fate that might have befallen a highly intelligent woman in that era. With this context in mind, the narrator examines the accomplishments of major nineteenth-century women novelists and contemplates the significance of literary tradition for aspiring writers. She then surveys the contemporary literary landscape by analyzing the debut novel of one of her peers. Woolf concludes the essay with a powerful call to action, urging her audience of women to embrace and expand upon the literary tradition that has been painstakingly passed down to them, and to ensure a better legacy for future generations of women writers.
No comments:
Post a Comment